Published on Sunday, September 23rd, 2007 by Jeff Parks under
Community.
I was waiting on a colleague the other day; and while waiting I came across this article in Scientific American Mind magazine that I wanted to share. It focuses on a new approach to leadership that pulls us out of the Industrial Revolution and into the Information Age.
In the past, telling people what to do and how to do their jobs was a necessity. Then again, there was a huge knowledge gap between the leader and the worker. Today that gap is virtually non-existent. Yet there are still many organizations functioning in this “top-down” / micro-management style.
The aforementioned article discusses how a new view on leadership is starting to take shape:
In this alternative view, effective leaders must work to understand the values and opinions of their followers—rather than assuming absolute authority—to enable a productive dialog with followers about what the group embodies and stands for and thus how it should act. By leadership, we mean the ability to shape what followers actually want to do, not the act of enforcing compliance using rewards and punishments.
In all my years leading others, I’ve never seen the “I have an important title and thou shalt listen to me” approach ever succeed.
Strike that. I have seen it be incredibly successful in the following ways:
Increasing Anxiety
Creating silos between people, departments, and data
Breading a corporate culture of mistrust
Destroying any creative process
Killing communication amongst team members
It’s troubling to me that a bottom-up leadership style would be something new to leaders today; especially in an era where community and mass collaboration are creating capacities never seen in our time.
My father taught me well in this domain. He was the Director of Engineering for DuPont Canada when he retired. Prior to this he was the site manager of the largest plant in Canada for several years.
The one lesson, amongst many, that he taught me is that everyone wants to feel like what they are doing is of value; and that they are valued in the process.
Given that good leadership depends on constituent cooperation and support, this new psychology of leadership negates the notion that leadership is exclusively a top-down process. In fact, it suggests that to gain credibility among followers, leaders must try to position themselves among the group rather than above it.
And who says soft skills aren’t as important as technical ones? In my mind, soft skills aren’t “soft”. They are, in fact, the hardest skills of all.
This “new view” on leadership suggests that if you are overseeing a group of people and you don’t have the ability to listen more than you speak or direct, you will not be successful in such a role.
I couldn’t agree more!
So how do you know if you are a micro-manager? In a related Blog post, this diagram was passed on to me from a friend and colleague. It provides an explanation for why the “old school” leadership style is backwards by today’s standards.

The most important function for a manager is X = -Y, where X is employee brain use and Y is degree of management.
If you are unsure if your style is that of top-down or “micro-manager”, ask yourself these questions:
1) Do you pride yourself on being “on top of” the projects or your direct reports? Do you have a solid grasp of the details of every project?
2) Do you believe that you could perform most of the tasks of your direct reports, and potentially do a better job?
3) Do you pride yourself on frequent communication with your employees? Does that communication include asking them for detailed status reports and updates?
3) Do you believe that being a manager means that you have more knowledge and skills than your employees, and thus are better equipped to make decisions?
4) Do you believe that you care about things (quality, deadlines, etc.) more than your employees?
Answering even a weak “yes” to any one of these might mean you either are–or are in danger of becoming–a micromanager. And once you go down that road, it’s tough to return.
Teams are brilliant examples of community. Start listening to your community as a leader; you’ll be blown away by the results!